Saturday, April 28, 2012

A Gamer on His Own Level





Online computer gaming (the kind that kids, not gamblers, play) has taken Asia by storm over the past decade. An acronym such as MMORPG (massively multiplayer online role playing game) may seem like a mouthful for most mortal humans, but it rolls easily off the tongue of most young Asian gamers. No one has benefited more from the trend than Kim Jung-Ju, also known as Jay Kim and the controlling shareholder of Nexon, who Forbes magazine lists as Korea’s third wealthiest person. His net worth is estimated at $4.3 billion. In a country dominated by a few huge business conglomerates such as Samsung and Hyundai that are controlled by second- or third-generation family ownership, Jay Kim’s scratch-to-riches story stands out as a singular achievement. There are other Korean internet entrepreneurs who have also made fortunes by creating companies such as NCsoft, Naver, Gmarket, Daum and others. But no one has done it with the control, savvy and personality cult that Jay Kim has managed to imbue through Nexon.

When I first met Jay Kim in 2002, Nexon was worth a mere $200 million or so. Though it was a pioneer in the burgeoning online gaming sector, its business presence was confined to Korea and an outpost in Japan and the US West Coast. What struck me more than anything about Jay back then was the clear long term vision he had for the business. He said he hoped to IPO the company in “10-20 years.” When asked why not sooner, he simply shrugged and said that he just wanted the company to build good games, and he was confident that the company would do so. Making a fast buck or achieving world domination were not top-of-mind to him back then.

But things changed steadily and inexorably over the ensuing years. His company’s growth exploded, particularly in China, where its games became some of the country’s most popular. With the company’s success, he received massive pressure from his employees to take the company public, eager as they were to cash in the fruits on their labors. Disney and Electronic Arts both approached him, and they and Nexon did multi-year dances to see whether they could buy out Jay Kim’s business. Ultimately, Jay did decide to IPO the company, feeling that he needed to do so in order to keep Nexon competitive on a global scale. He also made murmurings about the desire to relieve some of the burden off of his own shoulders by professionalizing ownership of the company. An IPO on the Tokyo Stock Exchange (not in Korea, the US or Hong Kong) was executed in 2011 in order to tap Japan’s large and stable domestic retail investor base. The IPO was Japan’s largest of 2011.

Rumors have surfaced this week that Nexon is now preparing a bid to buy out Electronic Arts, its former suitor. It is a delicious twist of fate, as the young padawan has become the master and the old men of the game universe have failed to keep up with the rapidly changing times.

Jay Kim’s detractors call him a boorish, selfish person who discards his former game developers and partners like so many used-up prepaid cards. In a conservative culture such as Korea's where upholding personal loyalties and relationships are considered de rigueur signs of good manners, his personal style is often frowned upon. However, I don’t think that Jay Kim much thinks what others care about him. If he did, he would not have risen out of the conformist masses so decisively to lay claim to such a lofty perch on top of Korea’s business community. He would not have set such a remarkable benchmark for entrepreneur success. And he would not have been able to have such a resounding impact on an industry which has become one of Korea’s best exports. In a word, Jay Kim has been a MetaMMORPGhosis. 

Details Here

Friday, April 27, 2012

Samsung Abbey - An Unroyal Feud



If South Korea had a king, it would be Lee Keun-hee. He is the country’s richest man. He is the Chairman of Samsung, Korea’s flagship business conglomerate, or chaebol. And, like so many other members of royalty worldwide, he is at the center of a dysfunctional family and its battles over money and power.

Sibling spats over inheritances are all-too-common the world over. However, such feuding is seldom played out publicly in decorum-obsessed Korea, especially amongst the elite families. Brothers and sisters don’t criticize each other in the media for being unfilial towards their deceased parents – that’s a serious no-no in a seriously Confucian society. But that’s what Lee Keun-hee – the third child of Samsung founder Kim Byung-Chul – has said about his eldest brother, Lee Maeng-hee. The accusation was in retaliation for the elder brother and Lee Keun-hee’s elder sister calling the Samsung Chairman “childish” and “greedy.”

At the heart of the matter is an equity stake in Samsung Life and other related companies currently worth over $600 million. Through an elaborate cross-ownership structure that would take a brigade of top-notched lawyers weeks to fully understand, Lee Keun-hee is able to exercise control over Samsung’s entire group (including Samsung Electronics) through Samsung Everland (a theme park and resort business) and Samsung Life. The ownership stake in question had been hidden away by the patriarch before his death in 1987 and ostensibly used during his life as a slush fund to influence politicians and curry favors. It seems that, until a few years ago, only Keun-hee amongst the family members knew about the shares. When the stash came to light through the handiwork of a whistle-blower who had worked under him, Keun-hee paid the requisite tax penalty, and then transferred the shares into his beneficial name, rather than divvying them amongst his siblings. His reasoning? The shares were his just deserts for having built Samsung into a world-beating business; his siblings were unworthy in his eyes, since they had been looking after other business interests over the past couple of decades. The court battles to come will bring up many arcane and complex legal issues, including those involving statute of limitations and inheritance law. Up for grabs is effective control of the Kingdom of Samsung itself.

The unfolding drama is a real-life soap opera that trumps the succession frenzy that recently took place across the border with North Korea’s leadership. It is the South Korea’s own reality show version of England’s Downton Abbey, but one that emphatically casts aside the stiff-lipped and starched manners of both cultures’ upper crust societies. From a purely entertainment perspective, let’s hope the show is only in its second season.

Details Here

Saturday, April 21, 2012

Shadow Banking and Its Pound of Flesh – UPDATE


“Rich Sister” Wu Ying’s execution for defrauding her investors has been stayed by China’s Supreme People’s Court. Congratulations to China’s judiciary system for joining the 21st century, at least on this particular case.

Details Here

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Shadow Banking and Its Pound of Flesh

Shadow Banking on Trial

"Rich Sister" Wu Ying weeps during sentencing for defrauding investors


The most shocking thing about the attached article on China’s “Rich Sister” is not so much her methods of having “illegally” raised money or her being accused of subsequently defrauding her investors, but rather, the pending punishment she is facing – execution. Borrowing or raising investment funds through informal, non-official “shadow banking” channels is an all-too-common occurrence in rapidly developing countries with tightly controlled banking systems. Not paying investors back - either because someone can’t or won’t – is, sadly, a misfortune as old as money itself. And showing off wealth obstentatiously through owning multiple homes, cars (including a $500,000 Ferrari) and alluringly placed tattoos is, well, almost a badge of honor in materialistic modern China. On the other hand, putting someone to death for committing a combination of the first two misdeeds (maybe compounded by the third) reflects much worse on the legal system than the culprit. Especially when the legal system belongs to the world’s latest superpower.

Shadow banking systems, wherein money is collected informally from individuals and lent to other small borrowers, arise when the official banking system does not meet the credit needs of small businesses or individuals. Often, as is the case in China today and was the case in Japan and Korea when they were developing at a similar pace 2-3 decades ago, the major banks focus on lending money to large, state-owned or –affiliated borrowers, to the detriment of smaller beneficiaries. This policy of lending big occurs in developing countries for a combination of reasons:


- Banks are directed by government policy to build up strategic industries;
- Banks get a bigger bang-for-the-buck in terms of assets, interest income and fees by lending to large corporate entities;
- Powerful people behind the large corporates are able to exert influence on banks;
- Developing banks lack the credit know-how to lend to small businesses and individuals and manage relationships with the borrowers.

China’s shadow banking is estimated to be between US $1.5 - $2.5 trillion – a staggering size that evidences just how vital this system has become in driving domestic investment. Similarly, in Korea during the height of the “curb”, or “gae”, market during the mid-1990s, informal loans represented 30-40% of total bank assets. In Korea and Japan, much of the market was administered by organized crime organizations. So failure to repay was dealt with harshly. However, the punishment was doled out outside of the official legal system, not as part of it.

“Rich Sister” is not the first person in China to be facing execution because of financial crimes. China has a history of regularly convicting and sentencing guilty persons to death. Interestingly, a high proportion of them are women, reflecting an unfortunate consequence when the ambitious nature of Chinese women collides with the fewer opportunities they have to borrow money through official channels. However, the case of “Rich Sister” has received the most media attention, by far. Rapidly-rising public frustration with domestic economic policies that are seen to unfairly favor the rich and privileged are a key factor.

The hopeful news is that the rattling of public discontent has not fallen on deaf ears. Officials as high as Wen Jiabao, China’s premier, have recently called for major reforms in the banking system, including break-up of the “monopoly” large banks and more systemic focus on promoting small entrepreneurs. This will take time, and reform and restructuring of China’s financial systems will be fraught with moral and ethical peril that will play out with dangerous consequences over the coming years. However, painful reform is surely a necessarily evil to address legal processes that belong more in the time of Shylock and medieval Venice than in the 21st century.

Details Here

Sunday, April 8, 2012

A Tale of Three Auctions


Ru Guanyao Brush Washer


It was a busy week for auctions in Hong Kong and involving Asian buyers. The takeaway? Appetite for rare and exotic items is alive and well, despite some uneven results and the uncertain global economic environment.

Auction #1: Sotheby's 5-day Spring Auction in Hong Kong concluded on April 4. The results were generally positive, but a bit more tempered than feverish auctions of the recent past. A total of US$320 million was spent over 2,784 lots - impressive figures but slightly lower than last autumn, when 3,000 lots worth $410 million were sold. The highlight of the auction was a modest-looking bowl (pictured above), which sold for almost $26.7 million - three times the estimate. This flower shaped ceramic is over 900 years old, and one of only five privately-held Song-dynasty brush washing bowls in existence made in the Ru Guanyao (government ceramic kilns) facility. Another highlight was the wine collection, which sold 100% of its lots at a 11% premium over its $7.4 million estimate. This result underscores that the fine wine market among Asian buyers is recovering in 2012 (the Liv-ex 100 Index was up 2.5% through Feb), after a precipitous drop-off in 2011. Lastly, top-end contemporary art such as this Zhang Xiaogang "Bloodline" series piece (shown below), did well, selling for $6.7 million, 50% above its estimate. An Indonesian and Vietnamese artist also set records.

However, there was a lack of depth of interest for contemporary art below the top-end. The huge appetite for modern pieces present in recent years was absent, perhaps reflecting the cautionary stance of "new money" Asian wealth below the super-rich. Still, the overall collection sold close to its pre-event estimate.     Details Here

Auction #2: Seoul Auction held its Spring Auction of Asian contemporary art in Hong Kong on Tuesday. Similar to the Sotheby's event, results were mixed, even though the auctioneers claimed satisfaction with the results. 41 out of the 64 lots sourced from around the region sold, for a total of $4.1 million. A piece by Whanki Kim - Korea's most revered modern artist - was auctioned at a pre-event estimate of c. $1.3 million.

Auction #3: On the other side of the world, an auction of a very different sort took place, for America's smallest town - Buford, Wyoming with a population of 1, set on 10+ acres with a convenience store, gas station and mobile home. In the internet auction, this lot also went to an Asian buyer, who bid $900,000. The anonymous Vietnamese buyer was quoted as saying that he was fulfilling a dream by owning a piece of America. He beat out other bids from 46 countries.

Perhaps he will need some interesting Asian art pieces and a wine cellar to keep himself company once he moves in.

'

Thursday, March 29, 2012

Para-dollar Shift



This morning's South China Morning Post displayed this pretty graph in the lead story of the Business section. It mixes two statistical trends that are not necessarily related - % increase in $100-millionaires per country may not have direct bearing on the % of global GDP contributed by various regions, or vice versa. However, the message is quite plainly stated: Asia's pockets are getting heavier faster than anywhere else.

Other interesting factoids pointed out in the Citi Private Bank / Knight Frank joint study:

- East Asia already surpasses North America and Western Europe in the number of $100-millionaires: 18,000 vs. 17,000 vs.14,000, respectively.

- Asia will extend that lead in the next five years, growing at 44.4%, vs 23% and 7% for N. America and W. Europe, respectively.

- On an individual country-by-country basis, the US will still hold a lead over China for a few more years. However, if super-wealth is like Olympic gold medals, that too will probably change.

- As far as global GDP is concerned, Developing Asia already chips in more than N. America and W. Europe. That lead will increase such that almost half the world's output could be produced by Asia in 2050. According to the study, the future is indeed red.

Of course, no growth trajectories are without their bumps and dips. If the words "China", "India", "Russia" were given as clues in a guess-the-topic TV game show, contestants would be forgiven for answering "corrupt and volatile nation-states" rather than "economic superpowers". Continued success for these countries depends in no small part on exogenous factors such as climate change, commodity prices and geopolitical stability. Still, the rise is expected to be both inexorable and disruptive.

And what will these rich folks do with their money? Make "investments of passion." No, that doesn't mean stuffing trust funds for a harem of under-aged mistresses  (although it could). The article refers to wine, art and sports teams. It could just as easily refer to vintage cars, landmark properties, rare watches - the list is endless.

Europe's rise over the centuries gave the world a legacy of beautiful buildings, art and legal (political and economic) systems. America's rise over the past century has given us super-efficient, globe-trotting corporate power. What will Asia's stamp on history be? Given how different the various cultures within the region are from each other, the picture is far from clear. I am neither dumb nor smart enough to make a detailed guess. However, I will be a fascinated observer.

Details Here

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Crisis? What Crisis?




This flyer came to me in the mail this past weekend from one of HK’s well-established real estate brokers. The area of Mid-Levels that is featured is predominantly populated by foreign professionals in Hong Kong on expatriate packages or housing allowances, and wealthy locals (although not the tycoons, who occupy the Peak and other even-more exclusive enclaves). The table below summarizes the dwellings on offer, translating the prices into US-dollars and calculating the amounts on a per-square foot basis.

The result? Hong Kong’s premium residential real estate is back at an all-time high, with prices rivaling the giddy times of early-1997, just prior to the Asian financial crisis. Back then, when the bubble burst, prices tumbled steadily over five years, during which time the market struggled through currency crashes throughout Asia, followed by the dotcom blow-up, Enron/WorldCom and other corporate shenanigans, and lastly SARS. When the market finally hit its nadir in 2003, it bottomed at close to 40% of 1997 levels. The buzzword that year in the real estate market was “negative-equity.” Ouch.

Since then, with only a brief dip (a decidedly false summit) following the global financial crisis of 2008, the Hong Kong property market has seen a steady, relentless climb to its current perch at the top of the world. The key drivers to the price rise have been a HK-dollar pegged to the chronically weak US-dollar and its low interest rates, and feverish buying by mainland Chinese.

It’s a well-known story, but the actual prices still are mind-boggling. Basically, nothing – not even a 400-square-foot unit that is barely big enough for a Hong Kong mistress and her shoe collection to stand upright in – sells for less than $2,000 / sq. ft. The average for the group is $3,175 / sq. ft. The most expensive listed, Dynasty Court, at $10.7 million, is priced at close to $5,000 a square foot. Yes, Dynasty Court has a stirring view of Hong Kong harbor, and the health club sure is well appointed. But that kind of money could buy an awful lot of pretty postcards and gym memberships, with money to spare for a lamborghini or two.

At the end of 2011, pundits were predicting a market correction of 20% or so for this year. Now, doomsayers are not quite so strident. Prices are up 5% month-on-month from February to March. The US-economy is on the mend, the euro-crisis is taking a few months off to catch its breath, and the Chinese government is starting to act in a more accommodative way to address slowing domestic economic growth. Of course, risk factors for the real estate market remain. The newly elected leader of Hong Kong, CY Leung, has set reining in runaway property prices as a key policy agenda. Furthermore, the euro-crisis is by no means resolved – thinking so could be like wiping yourself while seated on the potty before you are sure that you are done with business. And if China experiences a hard landing, Hong Kong property will likely collapse with it.

But don’t bet on any meaningful corrections in the near term. Hong Kong’s place in the world is unique. It is arguably the coolest place in the world to live now if making money is one's aim. So HKers had better get used to the idea of living in dramatically expensive, shoebox-sized dwellings. An address in Blahnik Estates, anyone?